Jury Foreperson: Judge Hunter was guilty
363 views · Published 23 October 2014 · 3:32 · Indexed 14 November 2026
Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2014 · News & Politics
HAMILTON COUNTY, Ohio (Angenette Levy) -- The jury deliberating the case against suspended Juvenile Court Judge Tracie Hunter found her guilty of one count and deadlocked in the remaining eight felonies. The jury found Hunter guilty of having Unlawful Interest in a Public Contract. The count stemmed from allegations that Hunter used her position to give her brother, Steven, documents relating to his job. Steven Hunter was a Hamilton Co. Juvenile Court employee who faced a disciplinary hearing. Hunter's attorney, Clyde Bennett, vowed to appeal the ruling. "I'm hurt, I'm stunned. I'm shocked. I thought as a matter of law she should have been found not guilty. Not as a matter of law but as a matter of evidence but as a matter of law," Bennett said Tuesday. Hunter was accused of eight felonies including tampering with evidence, forgery, theft in office and misusing a county credit card. Special prosecutors Scott Croswell and Merlyn Shiverdecker said Hunter back dated her rulings to prevent prosecutors from appealing her decisions. The outcome didn't surprise defense attorney Mark Krumbein, who watched the trial closely. "It was hard to understand. It was sort of inside baseball. Most non-attorneys wouldn't understand it, a lot of attorneys wouldn't understand it unless they perhaps practiced in juvenile court," Krumbein said. Jurors heard six weeks of testimony, arguments and saw countless exhibits. Jury foreperson Sandy Kirkham said she believed Judge Hunter was guilty. "I am extremely frustrated and disappointed with the result of our deliberations. The evidence presented by the prosecution was compelling and convincing. It is very disconcerning (sic) that a judge might so attempt to manipulate our judicial system without severe consequences," Kirkham said. She added that the majority of the jurors believed Hunter was guilty. The felony count could end Hunter's legal career. Judge Norbert Nadel had strong words for Hunter - the first African American woman to sit on the juvenile court bench. "Judge Hunter, this is a sad day for you, your supporters, our system of justice and your family," Nadel said. He also talked about the seriousness of violating the public trust. Judge Hunter left court surrounded by bodyguards. She had a smile on her face but didn't have anything to say. Her supporters still believe the prosecution of Judge Hunter was politically motivated since she won her seat on the bench in a hotly-contested race. "I've always said it was a continued fight from 2010. I still stand upon that. It was a big fight from 2010," said Hunter supporter Bishop Bobby Hilton. The special prosecutors in the case, Scott Croswell and Merlyn Shiverdecker, can retry Hunter on the eight felony counts since a verdict was not reached. But, neither will comment until Hunter is sentenced December 2. Judge Nadel could sentence Hunter to probation or anywhere from six to 18 months behind bars. Follow Angenette Levy on Twitter @angenette5, and LIKE her on Facebook.
More from this channel
-
2:50
Cincinnati Officer Indicted on Theft and Child Porn Charges -- LOCAL 12, WKRC-TV
-
0:48
Caesers CEO Addresses Chamber
-
0:36
$100 Million Dollar Cross Country Scam Involving Charity Donations
-
0:31
School Wants to Build Football Stadium
-
3:01
UC Player Dies in Accident in Butler County Saturday Night
-
3:08
Daily Sportscast: Tuesday, September 10
-
2:03
Brad and Lap talk Bengals 9-12
-
2:14
Daily Sportscast: Wednesday, September 11