Portune: Hunter retrial too expensive, divisive

125 views · Published 22 January 2015 · 3:48 · Indexed 4 November 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

HAMILTON COUNTY, Ohio (Angenette Levy) -- Tracie Hunter will go on trial for a second time in June but Hamilton Co. Commissioner Todd Portune said Wednesday that he doesn't think Hunter should be retried at all. 

Hunter appeared in court so Judge Patrick Dinkelacker could set a new trial date. Hunter spoke up when one of the special prosecutors accused of her playing games which prompted the following exchange.

Judge Patrick Dinkelacker: "You don't need to say anything." 

Tracie Hunter: "That's fine but make sure ..." 

Judge Patrick Dinkelacker:  "What did I just say?" 

Tracie Hunter:  "Make sure he does not disrespect me." 

Judge Patrick Dinkelacker: "I don't know what that means by you." 

Tracie Hunter:  "I don't play games. I don't play games. Make it clear."

Hunter asked Judge Dinkelacker to recuse himself from the case because he sat on the appeals court during Hunter's first trial. Dinkelacker declined. At a county commission meeting a short time later, Commissioner Todd Portune questioned whether there should be a second trial at all.

"I think that money could be put to a far better purpose than retrying these eight counts," Portune said. 

Portune says Hunter's first trial cost taxpayers more than $461,000 which does not include court house staffing costs. Some of Hunter's supporters also spoke to the county commissioners and asked that they talk to the Hamilton Co. Prosecutor's Office about stopping the second trial. 

"I'm just asking that somehow, cooler and calmer heads prevail. This is not an ax murderer," said Rev. Damon Lynch III. 

Special prosecutors Merlyn Shiverdecker and Scott Croswell are prosecuting the case. They were appointed by the court and made the decision to retry Hunter on eight counts that a jury deadlocked on last year. 

"I think that far more negative is going to occur overall to Hamilton County than any good that could come of spending that much money on retrying her on those counts," Portune told Local 12 News. 

Portune said the county couldn't balance its budget this year without making cuts and the cost of a second trial will come out of the county's general fund. Commissioner Chris Monzel said he understands Portune's financial concerns but the county's hands are tied.

"We don't want to go out and waste a bunch of money we don't have to," Monzel said. "Unfortunately though, given the situation, we have no control over this. When you're dealing with special prosecutors by Ohio law we have to pay the bill whatever they determine to do."

Monzel said there's a separation between the county commission and the legal system. Meanwhile, Portune hopes someone will listen to him.

"As a county I think we need to look forward and not on continually looking backward." 

Hamilton County's Administrator Christian Sigman said Hunter's retrial will cost less than the first trial. Sigman said the county must pay the bill for the special prosecutor or it will be in violation of a court order. But Portune asked him to look into that claim further and get a legal opinion from the county prosecutor's office. 

Hunter's trial date was set for June 1. She is appealing her conviction on unlawful interest in a public contract.

Follow Angenette Levy on Twitter @angenette5, and LIKE her on Facebook.

More from this channel