Family of investigators say they have motive and suspect in Katelyn Markham murder
1,635 views · Published 5 February 2015 · 4:22 · Indexed 25 October 2026
Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics
CINCINNATI (Deborah Dixon) -- When it comes to finding a killer, Frank smith is one of the best.
The retired detective has his own private business and with the help of his wife and daughter, this family of investigators is now on the trail of the person who murdered Katelyn Markham.
Daughter Sarah Schwartz is a deception analyst certified by homeland security.
She gives her read on an interview and so does wife Connie who digs into dark pasts.
"What did you find? In court records several things that could make this our suspect."
Photos on the wall include cases Smith cracked as a detective, including the arrest of a serial killer.
He says the women in his office have instincts that keep him from getting tunnel vision.
"Investigators get tunnel vision, said Frank. They hone in one suspect that's a fatal mistake.
Frank believes that the investigators had tunnel vision in the Katelyn Markham case.
The art student disappeared from her Fairfield condo in 2011.
Her body was found in an Indiana roadside dump two years later.
Smith is working with both police departments, but his team started over.
"It didn't matter if another agency looked at a person polygraphed or interviewed, said Frank. We did it again."
Facebook helps them stay connected to Katelyns friends and the curious.
Connie sees the case as a mother.
"Who prevented me from having grandchildren? I would want to know this who did this? I would want justice. said Connie.
Several people in Katelyns case have ended up in the hot seat of Frank's polygraph office.
The latest in polygraphs assess heart rate, blood pressure respiration and sweat, then the computer calculates the mathematical odds you're lying.
"Most emotions show 1/25th of a second happen without you trying, said daughter Sarah Schwartz.
Sarah does her own interviews. The deception analyst measures everything from the way someone swallows to the blink of an eye.
"You can try [to hide], but we'll catch it. But 1/25th of a second it will before you can change it, said Sarah.
Frank keeps Katelyns photo where the team can see it.
"I want them to look at it, said Frank. Do not forget what happened. Never give up no matter what."
Frank Smith believes Katelyns picture will end up on the office wall. The one with cases closed.
Katelyn's father says he's encouraged by the work the family is doing, but he's afraid to get his hopes up.
"When you have a week, get hopes up and that week goes by its a week you didn't live your life, said Dave Markham, Katelyns father.
The reward for information that finds Katelyns killer is now at $70,000.
You can follow Frank and the family on Facebook at Ohio Polygraph
More from this channel
-
2:50
Cincinnati Officer Indicted on Theft and Child Porn Charges -- LOCAL 12, WKRC-TV
-
0:48
Caesers CEO Addresses Chamber
-
0:36
$100 Million Dollar Cross Country Scam Involving Charity Donations
-
0:31
School Wants to Build Football Stadium
-
3:01
UC Player Dies in Accident in Butler County Saturday Night
-
3:08
Daily Sportscast: Tuesday, September 10
-
2:03
Brad and Lap talk Bengals 9-12
-
2:14
Daily Sportscast: Wednesday, September 11