081816 INNOCENT MAN RELEASED FROM PRISON AFTER ALMOST TWO DECADES
2,104 views · Published 18 August 2016 · 28:26 · Indexed 29 October 2026
Channel: SCOTT ENGLE-MONTGOMERY COUNTY POLICE REPORTER- · 2016 · News & Politics
It was an emotional scene in the 410th District Court of Montgomery County Thursday, as an 18 year-long child murder case was finally brought to a close. In the court of Judge K. Michael Mayes, Neal Hampton Robbins’ capital murder charge was dismissed. In 1998, he was arrested in connection to the death of 17-month-old Tristen Rivet and convicted of capital murder in 1999. The ruling was spurred by the recension of the testimony of the, then, Associate Harris County Medical Examiner, Patricia Moore, which had been the lynchpin of the prosecution’s case nearly two decades ago. Without the benefit of this false testimony, the case against Robbins fell through, based on insufficient evidence. “The issues that this case presented over the course of the last decade are novel, difficult, complicated, and unfortunately it caused some of the best legal minds in the state to respectfully disagree” defense attorney Brian Wice said. “Junk science and junk scientists are responsible for wrongful convictions as surely as bad confessions and bad ID’s.” In 2007, when reviewing this case, Moore decided there was no factual basis on which to claim homicide and so changed Rivet’s cause of death to undetermined. As Montgomery County District Attorney Brett Ligon noted, the case is one of many that Patricia Moore’s testimony has been flipped on. “I hope Patricia is never allowed to touch another person or child to do anything like what they’ve put me and my family through for the past 18 years,” Barbara Hope, the victim’s mother, said. It took nine long years fraught with false-starts and overturned rulings, however, for Robbin’s appeals to be processed and finalized. “Better to get it right than to get it first” attorney Brian Wice said. Barbara Hope, however, believes they had it right the first time and still doubts the innocence of her former boyfriend and the defendant, Robbins. “Eighteen years ago, what you had is the testimony offered up from an ME. Twelve jurors indicted him based on that testimony and 12 jurors convicted him,” Ligon said. “If you’ll notice, we’re not saying that Mr. Robbins is innocent…The dismissal is based upon insufficient evidence. The burden of proof on the state is to prove this case beyond reasonable doubt and there is not enough evidence left after the testimony of the ME to get anywhere close to that standard.” Many question why this process took so long after the former ME, Patricia Moore, reviewed the case with better-trained eyes and amended her original prognosis. Judge Hayes, who recommended a new trial in both 2010 and 2013, said, “In our world of hurry-up technology and Olympic speed, decision making in our justice system often seems archaic and distressingly slow. Our courts often move so slow that the pain of final resolution seems out of touch with what our society expects and longs for. In a real sense, however, we all know that finding the truth takes time.” The case of Neal Robbins took many years and many denied appeals. In the end, due process took hold and ended with the return of freedom to a man long incarcerated. Around 1:30 Thursday afternoon, Robbins left the jail, sans jumpsuit and shackles a free man. “I guess rediscovering what life is like in the 21st century, learning how to use a smartphone and the internet and an ATM card,” attorney Brian Wice said. “I don’t think any of us can put ourselves in his shoes- I mean 1998 was a very long time ago and when you’re Neal’s age and you hear your sentence isn’t a number but a noun, the rest of your life’s a very long time and I just hope that Neal is able to walk into the 21st century and acclimate himself.” BELOW IS FULL UNCUT VIDEO OF JUDGE MAYES ORDER FOR DISMISSAL AND COMMENTS FROM THE VICTIMS MOTHER, ROBBINS ATTORNEY AND ROBBINS WALKING OUT OF THE MONTGOMERY COUNTY JAIL A FREE MAN
More from this channel
-
1:47
050307 WHOOSH
-
8:00
050709 CONROE YOUTH BASEBALL VS. PARENTS
-
1:50
010213 COUNTRY WEST ARSON FIRES
-
3:08
010213 MCSO DEPUTY SHOOTS AT SUSPECT
-
17:58
123112 NEW YEARS EVE DWI TASK FORCE
-
5:45
122512 DACUS AUTO VS BUILDING
-
6:43
031907 MVA 105 AT FM3083
-
6:47
SHSU To Participate In Interagency Active-Shooter Exercise