Housing court judge hands down stiff sentence
2,777 views · Published 16 January 2015 · 3:44 · Indexed 26 October 2026
Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics
WALNUT HILLS (Rich Jaffe) -- Refuse to fix the neighborhood eyesore and lose your freedom.
A Kenwood couple got a serious wake-up call on Tuesday from Hamilton Countys new Housing Court Judge.
He sent the husband to jail for 180 days.
The sentence comes after years of haggling between the property owners and both city and county officials over a property they own in Walnut Hills.
Housing court is a great and rather unique venue for dealing with problem property owners.
While the Housing Court Judge has lots of options to get people to bring their properties up to code, the last resort, jail, is always out there as a possibility.
On Tuesday, that harsh possibility became the only remaining option for Jeffrey Smith and his wife Melissa, and it's a tough lesson.
One look at 1311 Lincoln Avenue in Walnut Hills and you know it's a problem.
Broken windows, boarded up doorways not just an eyesore but a fire hazard and longtime neighborhood problem.
If you're wondering "who owns this place?" then you should meet Jeffrey and Melissa Smith.
This afternoon, Melissa Smith made a tearful, emotional plea to Housing Court Judge Brad Greenberg asking him not to send them to jail.
This has just snowballed, said Melissa Smith. One minute he's getting in trouble, the next minute Im getting in trouble. The sheriff's come out to our home and arrest us in front of our daughter and take us out in handcuffs in front of our neighbors.
Apparently the Smith's still didn't get the message.
Judge Greenberg agreed with Prosecutor Keith Foreman that the Smiths were playing games with the court.
Jeffrey Smith has owned the troubled building as an investment property since 1980 but since June of 2012, city building, fire inspectors, prosecutors and even probation officers have been trying to get the Smiths to fix serious problems with the structure.
The city even forced the tenants out and locked and boarded up the building because it was so unsafe, but they say the Smiths continued to ignore orders to fix the problems.
I count this as about the 17th time they've been in court, said Judge Greenburg. The goal of housing court the entire time has been just to get people into compliance.
Today Jeffrey Smith claimed city inspectors had no right to enter the building and take these pictures.
He and his wife claimed they couldn't enter the building and fix it because city officials locked the door, even though all they had to do was ask for a key or cut the lock.
Fed up with excuses, Judge Greenberg sentenced Jeffrey Smith to 6 months in jail, probation and orders to fix the building continue for his wife.
Judge Greenberg said that Melissa Smith has a clear opportunity here. She can fix the fire code violations, bring the building into compliance with the orders and her husband could get out of jail.
Judge Greenberg volunteered for the seat when the previous judge, Russel Mock moved on to the appeals court.
Clearly this is a judge job that Greenberg is going to take very seriously.
Both the Smiths were in for a probation violation hearing on Tuesday.
Judge Mock put them on probation in September of last year for all the violations.
They were also in court on Tuesday because court officials say they refused to participate in a competency hearing.
Follow Jeff Hirsh on Twitter @local12jeff, and LIKE him on Facebook.
Follow us on Twitter @Local12 and LIKE us on Facebook for updates!
More from this channel
-
2:50
Cincinnati Officer Indicted on Theft and Child Porn Charges -- LOCAL 12, WKRC-TV
-
0:48
Caesers CEO Addresses Chamber
-
0:36
$100 Million Dollar Cross Country Scam Involving Charity Donations
-
0:31
School Wants to Build Football Stadium
-
3:01
UC Player Dies in Accident in Butler County Saturday Night
-
3:08
Daily Sportscast: Tuesday, September 10
-
2:03
Brad and Lap talk Bengals 9-12
-
2:14
Daily Sportscast: Wednesday, September 11