Judge denies Hunter's second request for new trial

104 views · Published 11 December 2014 · 0:37 · Indexed 19 November 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

CINCINNATI (WKRC) -- Judge Norbert Nadel denied Tracie Hunter's second request for a new trial. 

Tracie Hunter was convicted in October on one felony count of unlawful interest in a public contract. Defense attorney Clyde Bennett said the jury foreperson never should have been on the case because she failed to reveal key personal information during jury selection. 

Bennett said that juror had been sexually abused by a pastor when she was a teenager and because Judge Hunter is also a pastor, the juror was prejudiced against Hunter.

Bennett said if he knew the juror's background before the case began, he would have dropped her from the jury and claimed she lied when asked was she ever the victim of a crime. But special prosecutor Scott Croswell said the juror was completely truthful, because the incident was not considered a crime in Ohio back when it happened as long as the victim was of the age of consent.

In his ruling, Judge Nadel wrote that "Hunter failed to show that she was prejudiced by the juror's alleged failure to reveal incidents which allegedly occurred approximately forty years ago. In addition, these incidents never involved any type of criminal charges or conviction."

Judge Nadel recently rejected another attempt by Hunter for a new trial. The defense claimed three jurors changed their minds after signing the jury form and actually wanted to vote not guilty. But Judge Nadel said allowing that kind of switch would be chaos for the judicial system.

Judge Nadel said he'll sentence Hunter on Friday. He could sentence Hunter to up to 18 months in prison.



Follow us on Twitter @Local12 and LIKE us on Facebook for updates!

More from this channel