The case against physicalism: Russellian monism | Philip Goff | Consciousness Live!

3,294 views · Published 25 July 2018 · 2:00:36 · Indexed 16 November 2026

Channel: onemorebrown · 2018 · Education

Watch on YouTube

Philip Goff on his case against physicalism and for Russellian monism: cognitive phenomenology, phenomenal concepts and the difference between transparent and opaque concepts, geometric concepts and essences, his consciousness+ view, zombies and conceivability, Sam Coleman's view, whether consciousness is revealed as simple, grounding physicalism, structural realism and string theory, entanglement and a conscious universe.

0:00 Introduction
1:09 Russellian monism
5:10 Arguing that physicalism is false
7:58 Thought and cognitive phenomenology
10:18 Third-person observation
15:15 Does experience represent reality?
18:00 The experience itself as target
20:12 Sharing concepts
23:00 What's gone wrong
25:14 Behavioral concepts of pain
30:21 The success of physical science
32:35 Will science one day explain consciousness?
35:22 Descartes and intelligent behavior
37:37 We'll do it one day
40:27 Adam Pautz's recent work
42:45 An intelligible account
45:28 Phenomenal concepts
47:49 Finding common ground
50:02 Transparent and opaque concepts
52:33 Geometric concepts
55:33 The essence of triangularity
57:47 A sphere with the mass of the earth
1:00:34 The consciousness+ view
1:02:45 Experiential nature
1:07:47 Completely opaque concepts
1:12:49 Churchland and imaginability
1:15:07 Are zombies conceivable?
1:18:00 Dual carving
1:20:21 A constrained exemption
1:22:36 Sam Coleman's view
1:25:21 Simplicity
1:27:36 Consciousness revealed as simple
1:30:25 Grounding physicalism
1:32:42 What we don't know
1:35:29 Structural realism
1:37:40 String theory
1:40:34 Accounting for consciousness
1:42:51 Experiential concepts
1:45:05 Making sense of string theory
1:47:51 Entangled particles and the whole
1:50:04 A review of the book
1:52:55 Consciousness is unobservable
1:55:13 A conscious cosmos?
1:57:30 Zombie parts of a conscious universe
2:00:18 Wrap-up

Episode page with full transcript: https://onemorebrown.com/consciousness-live/s1e3-philip-goff/

Philip’s website: http://www.philipgoffphilosophy.com

Philip’s blog: https://conscienceandconsciousness.com

Richard Dawid paper: http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/1240/1/re%2Bstr.PDF

Daniel Stoljar’s review of Philip’s book: 
https://ndpr.nd.edu/news/consciousness-and-fundamental-reality/

★ Enjoying the show? Follow & rate Consciousness Live! → https://onemorebrown.com/consciousness-live/rate/

More from this channel