Deters to Portune: Mind your own business

412 views · Published 23 January 2015 · 3:30 · Indexed 29 October 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

HAMILTON COUNTY, Ohio (Angenette Levy) -- Hamilton County's prosecutor fired back Thursday, Jan. 22, at county commissioner Todd Portune after he said suspended juvenile court judge Tracie Hunter should not be retried on eight felony counts because it will cost taxpayers too much money.

"It's purely political in my mind," Joe Deters said in an interview with Deborah Dixon. 

Deters said his office does not have anything to do with the decision to retry Hunter. He said Merlyn Shiverdecker and Scott Croswell were appointed as special prosecutors by the court. Shiverdecker and Croswell made the decision to retry Hunter. Deters said he thinks Portune 

"In my mind I think he's pandering to a demographic that is upset about this, specifically African-Americans in this community," Deters said. "I think this is what this is about. He's not a stupid individual. He knows he has no authority at all to tell the Court of Common Pleas not to do this."

Portune said Thursday he would not get into "a war of words" with Joe Deters. 

"My approach to this is to look at this objectively as a steward of the public money," Portune told Local 12 News Wednesday. "The fact of the matter is as that steward of the public money that spending this much more money on a retrial is going to serve a good and valid purpose." 

Portune said he would feel the same way if a white, male Republican was in the same situation as Hunter. Deters also spoke about Hunter. 

"It's very unfortunate what's occurred here. I think she needs help. I really do. It's sad. And it's sad that people address this as a racial issue because it's not," Deters said. 

Local 12 News showed Deters' comment to two of Hunters' staunchest supporters:  Cecil Thomas and Bishop Bobby Hilton. Thomas and Hilton called the comment an attempt at "character assassination."

"Now everybody, after seeing that first trial, after seeing the travesty of injustice that has occurred here, now all of the sudden he's trying to find a way to say maybe she's crazy and we know that that's just not the case," Thomas said. "Joe Deters needs to be removed if anybody."

Hilton echoed Thomas's sentiment. 

"She has a lot of stress upon her with all of the - she's only trying to do what is right. And she was only trying to follow the law and I know this." 

Hunter's attorney, Clyde Bennett, called her a "brilliant judge and lawyer".  

"Judge Hunter does not have any mental or psychological infirmaries or conditions. She is a very normal woman. In fact, she is remarkably brilliant and very intelligent. I give no credence whatsoever to anyone intimating that something is wrong with her because nothing is wrong with her," Bennett said. 

Hunter is appealing her conviction on one count of unlawful interest in a public contract. Her retrial is scheduled for June 1. 

Follow Angenette Levy on Twitter @angenette5, and LIKE her on Facebook.

More from this channel