Jury recommends life in prison for Dooley

154 views · Published 22 October 2014 · 0:55 · Indexed 1 November 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

BURLINGTON, Ky. (Angenette Levy) -- The jury in David Dooley's murder trial recommended Friday the judge sentence the former janitor to life in prison for the murder of Michelle Mockbee. 

 The jury deliberated the sentence for less than two hours Friday morning. Before deliberations on the sentencing, the jurors heard testimony from David Dooley's wife, Janet, and Michelle Mockbee's husband, Dan. The jury found Dooley guilty of murder and tampering with evidence after 20 hours of deliberations. 
 
"We're just very thankful for the best possible outcome we could have gotten this morning," said Jennifer Schneider-Ernst, Mockbee's sister. She added, "Too bad it's not an eye for an eye but we got the best we could get and we're very thankful for that. The jury got it right." 
 
Dooley was a janitor at Thermo Fisher Scientific in Florence where Michelle and Dan Mockbee worked. On May 29, 2012, Michelle Mockbee arrived at work earlier than usual to work on payroll. It was the day after Memorial Day. The Commonwealth's Attorney suggested Mockbee caught David Dooley breaking into her office - possibly by trying to pry open the door with a screwdriver. The Commonwealth said the pry marks on the door were consistent with a screwdriver found in the janitor's closet. 
 
 Linda Tally Smith said Dooley's wife, Janet, had a contract to clean the offices of Thermo Fisher Scientific for $1,200 per month. But, the Dooleys clocked in to clean the warehouse area. Smith suggested David Dooley was clocking in to clean the offices and essentially being paid twice. She also suggested Dooley was clocking in his wife on days she wasn't there. Smith implied Dooley may have been trying to steal their time cards. Dooley's mother said Friday she stands by her son. 
 
"I believe in his innocence. My son did not do this and I hope that one day they do find out who killed Michelle Mockbee," Elizabeth Yates said. Yates added that she believes unidentified DNA found on a piece of evidence at the crime scene could one day exonerate her son. 
 
The State argued Dooley may have killed Michelle Mockbee with a tape gun. Her skull was crushed and her arms were bound behind her back with packing tape.  However, the murder weapon was never found. The Commonwealth said there was "no smoking gun" in the case and Dooley's inconsistent statements and odd behavior indicated guilt. His DNA was not found on evidence that was tested.

Jurors were allowed to hear evidence of David Dooley's four prior felony convictions when considering his sentence. That evidence was not allowed at trial. 
 
Michelle Mockbee's sister said Friday he does not want people to forget about her sister who was a wife, mother, sister and daughter.  
 
"Michelle was amazing," Schneider-Ernst said. She added, "We're going to go on. We're going to cherish her memory and we're going to keep her spirit alive." 
 
 Judge James Schrand will formally sentence David Dooley November 19. 






Follow Angenette Levy on Twitter @angenette5, and LIKE her on Facebook.

More from this channel