SPECIAL REPORT: Charity Watch Dog Groups rate Humane Society of U.S.

2,424 views · Published 22 May 2013 · 3:20 · Indexed 29 October 2026

Channel: FOX NASHVILLE · 2013 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

Charity Watch Dog Groups rate Humane Society of U.S.Stacy CaseNashville    A Fox follow up on the Humane Society of the United States. In a Fox 17 special report, we pointed out the Humane Society of the U.S. primarily lobbies for legislation to protect animals and helps in large scale rescues.  We also reported that it is not set up to fund local shelters.  Now, we take a closer look at how three charity watchdog groups rate the HSUS.  About four thousand animals make their way through the  Nashville Humane Association each year.  A no kill
shelter, in a state that euthanizes more than 7 thousand animals a year. 
Though the national organization, the Humane Society of the United States, doesn't fund local shelters like this one, Joy Beach with the Nashville Humane Association says HSUS  has
an enormous amount of resources and expertise and equipment that no other
shelter does.  She says, when there's a major issue, HSUS  brings in their resources, expertise and equipment to help  out. 

  HSUS is the
nation's largest animal protection organization (take this
straight from tax document in the original piece 4/29/13  Humane
Society)   and tax records show, it took in $133 million dollars in
2011.  

 

Nat: from dog rescue
video

 

(bring the 3 logos
on screen.. one at a time.. triple screen- Charity Watch, Charity Navigator,
Better Business Bureau) So how do Charity Navigator, Charity Watch and the Better Business
Bureau rate HSUS? 

 

(add in sound effect
when Charity Navigator wipes onto screen.. something like a swoosh, but not a
swoosh.. something different for effect) 

 

Let's start with
Charity Navigator. (pull out 4 stars from the website)  Four stars overall, (pull out 3 stars
from website ) and three in the financial category.    

 

Nat: Wayne Pacelle
says from the podium 10:36:18 there are a few major issues 

 

(show wayne pacelle
at the podium) 

  It's a designation HSUS CEO and President Wayne Pacelle is proud
of.  

 

Wayne Pacelle/ HSUS
CEO  President  10:26:22 I'm very pleased
about it.  10:26:24

 

  But Charity
Watch paints a much different picture, (bring the D up from
the website)  giving HSUS a D noting the animal protection group gives
about half their budget toward actual charitable programs.    

 

(it's a skype
interview .. you may need to cover some of this if mouth is delayed ) 

Daniel Borochoff /
Charity Watch 15:07:50 We think groups ought to give 60%. The better groups give 75% or
more of their money towards charitable programs. 15:08:06 

 

  
Charity Watch says its evaluation process is more in depth than any other
charity watchdog group. 

 

Daniel Borochoff/
Charity Watch   15:12:25 you need to go
line by line and actually look and see what they do which is what we did with
the hsus... because you could see that a lot of the money they claim is
program  is actually fundraising solicitations.

 

  Mailers
like this....  magazines...   

 

stacy : 15:09:09 you're saying they bundle the education component with the
solicitation for money into one thing mail it to your house.. and they call it
a program when it's really.. I guess more of an ad? 

daniel answers:
15:09:21 to raise money you have to talk about something. *****15:09:48  so think about if you would like for your charitable
dollars go to pay for more solicitations, then hey give to the hsus.  10:08:08 It's (cut also)  costing them $48 dollars to
raise $100 dollars. We think it's too high.

 

Pacelle responds
this way: 

 

  Pacelle
responds: 10:26:31 They do a very narrow sort of metric on evaluating finances.
Anybody can call themselves a charity watchdog group, but the main charity
monitoring groups are the BBB   charity navigator.  10:26:46 

 

  Charity
Watch has been an independent charity rater for 21 years. (show BBB website, pull out check mark and meets
standards)   And, yes, Pacelle is correct, the BBB says HSUS meets the
standards of an accredited BBB charity.  

   

Wayne Pacelle
10:25:52 We think we're the most effective animal protection organization
that exists in the country. 

 

Nat: animal expo 

 

   One
of its tangible programs is this Animal Expo held in Nashville this month which
attracted more than 2 thousand animal welfare advocates.  

 

  Charity
Watch says more spending like this on direct animal welfare would go a long way
toward improving its charity rating.  

 WE WILL CONTINUE TO FOLLOW CALLS FOR AN I-R-S INVESTIGATION INTO THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES' TAX EXEMPT STATUS.

More from this channel