Howard Ain, Troubleshooter: Insurance recommendations for repair work

47 views · Published 6 July 2015 · 2:26 · Indexed 25 October 2026

Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

CINCINNATI (Howard Ain) -- How much protection do you have if something goes wrong with the repair company recommended by your insurance company? That's what a local woman wanted to know after things didn't work out so well with the roofer she hired. Ashley Hicks of Delhi was trying to avoid being ripped off by fly-by-night contractors. People were telling her she needed a new roof and she was being cautious. We had a storm in April and there was people knocking on our front doors passing out flyers to come repair the roof," she said.      Hicks said she didn't know what to do, so she called her insurance company, They recommended a roofing company so I called him, he came out and he started the claim."      She got an insurance check for ,600 for a new roof. Then she wrote a check to Shawn Miller, the roofer recommended by her insurance agent's office. But she never saw Miller again. After a week she found out Miller was arrested the day after she paid him and charged with five counts of theft and for engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity. "The police officer I was working with said they're all case kind of like mine that he would say he was going to do a roof, start the claim, take the person's money and not do the work." Although Miller was in jail, what about the rest of his company? Hicks called but said the phone was disconnected. She sent a registered letter but it was returned. Now she said she doesn't have enough money to pay for the needed roof. Hicks said she was shocked that, while trying to make sure she didn't get scammed, her insurance company would give her a bad recommendation and wouldn't reimburse her. "I'm not sure why they didn't fully check him out just to make sure. He had six open felonies for the same type behavior. I feel like they should have found that somehow before recommending him to me," she said.      So for people to protect themselves anytime they hire someone to do work in their home, here are some important tips: 1. Hire a contractor who is licensed and insured.      2. Get a detailed contract with start and completion dates and make the contractor responsible for all permits.      3. Don't pay more than 10 percent of the contract upfront.      4. Finally, ask your insurance company for a list of their "approved contractors" because the insurance company will stand behind their work if there's a problem.      After Local 12 pointed out exactly what Hicks did, her insurance company immediately sent her a check for all the money she had paid. Shawn Miller is in the Butler County jail on 5,000 bond. He's scheduled to go on trial August 2015.   Follow us on Twitter @Local12 and LIKE us on Facebook for updates

More from this channel