Appeals court upholds gay marriage ban
213 views · Published 17 November 2014 · 2:29 · Indexed 10 November 2026
Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2014 · News & Politics
CINCINNATI (Angenette Levy) -- A federal appeals court ruled Thursday that voters should decide whether states should recognize and allow same-sex marriage. The ruling from the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals dealt with cases in Ohio, Kentucky, Michigan and Tennessee. Couples in Ohio had sued in federal court for the right to list married, same-sex couples as parents on birth certificates. Two couples in Ohio sued to be listed as married on a spouse's death certificate. The Ohio cases dealt with the state recognizing same-sex marriages performed in states where it is legal. The attorney representing the plaintiffs in the Ohio cases said she was surprised by the appeals court ruling. "We are really disappointed in the 6th Circuit ruling today. The 6th Circuit is the only circuit in the country that has allowed these gay marriage bans to stay in place," said attorney Jennifer Branch. In the 2-1 decision, Judge Jeffrey Sutton wrote: "Better in this instance, we think, to allow change through customary political processes, in which the people, gay and straight alike, become the heroes of their own stories by meeting each other not as adversaries in a court system but as fellow citizens seeking to resolve a new social issue in a fair-minded way." Judge Martha Craig Daughtrey wrote the dissent. "The author of the majority opinion has drafted what would make an engrossing TED Talk or, possibly, an introductory lecture in Political Philosophy. But as an appellate court decision, it wholly fails to grapple with the relevant constitutional question in this appeal," Daughtrey wrote. Phil Burress of Citizens for Community Values said Judge Sutton "got it right." "This is an issue that needs to be decided by we the people. The judges need to but out of this," Burress said. Burress spearheaded Ohio's constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage in 2004. Voters passed it overwhelmingly. "There is no such thing as a federal marriage license. So this is a states' rights issue and the federal court should not be involved in this at all," Burress said. Burress said he's not sure the U.S. Supreme Court will hear an appeal since it declined to review petitions arising from challenges to state bans last month. Jennifer Branch believes the high court will hear arguments on the cases. "The U.S. Supreme Court will be hearing from the Ohio plaintiffs," Branch said. Ohio Attorney General Mike Dewine's office defended Ohio's same-sex marriage ban in federal court. Spokesman Dan Tierney said Thursday "The Ohio Attorney Generals Office is pleased the Court agreed with our arguments that important issues such as these should be determined through the democratic process." In Kentucky, a federal judge struck down that state's ban and labeled it "unconstitutional." In Thursday's ruling, Judge Sutton wrote that the bans on same-sex marriage are not unconstitutional. Kentucky Gov. Steve Beshear released this statement Thursday: "Today we took another step toward what Kentucky and this nation need: A United States Supreme Court ruling that establishes clear direction for states across the country on this divisive issue. I said all along that we needed clarity and certainty in Kentucky, and a lower court's ruling was not sufficient. I expect the plaintiffs to appeal this ruling quickly, and I urge the Supreme Court to take up this issue." Follow Angenette Levy on Twitter @angenette5, and LIKE her on Facebook.
More from this channel
-
2:50
Cincinnati Officer Indicted on Theft and Child Porn Charges -- LOCAL 12, WKRC-TV
-
0:48
Caesers CEO Addresses Chamber
-
0:36
$100 Million Dollar Cross Country Scam Involving Charity Donations
-
0:31
School Wants to Build Football Stadium
-
3:01
UC Player Dies in Accident in Butler County Saturday Night
-
3:08
Daily Sportscast: Tuesday, September 10
-
2:03
Brad and Lap talk Bengals 9-12
-
2:14
Daily Sportscast: Wednesday, September 11