SPECIAL REPORT: Pump Fiction - Scott Couch
1,240 views · Published 10 May 2013 · 3:21 · Indexed 18 November 2026
Channel: FOX NASHVILLE · 2013 · News & Politics
NASHVILLE, Tenn. - Pump fact versus pump fiction. With gas prices coming down, you might be tempted to treat your car to a tank of midgrade or premium. Will it make your vehicle run better or go further between fill ups? FOX17 investigates. Matt Badstiber is a discriminating driver. He loves his car and goes out of his way to fill up at a market in Franklin where they sell 100% pure gasoline. No ethanol added. Badstiber's also an engineer at a local car manufacturing plant.I'm getting about 10% better mileage and it costs about 8-10% more, says Badstiber. I think the benefit is the engine runs better.For most people, however, the choice is more basic. Will it be regular, midgrade or premium?I normally get regular, says Brentwood High School Senior Asa Duvall. One because it's cheap, and 2 because, just because that's just what my car takes.If 87 octane gas is good, surely 89 and 93 is better. After all, don't you get what you pay for?I know the purification is supposed to be different with different grades, says motorist Nicole McCoin.From what I hear premium is a, it's got some additive in it that makes it run smoother for better engines, says motorist Patrick Kelly.Some people think that, but turns out it's pump fiction. Name brand retailers add the same detergents to all their fuels.A lot of people used premium gas thinking that it was going to help their car in the long run in terms of promoting longevity and it was true back then, says Senior Consumer Advice Editor at Edmunds.com Philip Reed. It's no longer true because there are very strict government regulations for additives to keep your car running.Reed says there's a fine line between gas graces and even brand names versus no name gas. Reed says today's cars are designed to adjust to whatever grade of fuel you put in it.The car is essentially tuning itself as it drives, says Reed.So, should you ever buy premium gas? For most drivers, the answer is no. It won't make your car run any better and it doesn't improve gas mileage. Even when premium is recommended, the experts say most cars run well on 87 octane.It's a lot of money, says motorist Lee Ann Rehorn. If you buy a car that requires that, then that's something you need to factor in.Rehorn hit the nail on the head. The only time you should buy premium is when the manufacturer says it's required, like a Nissan 370Z. Mike Higginbotham is a product specialist at Nissan's North American headquarters in Cool Springs.A customer like this wants to drive a little bit sportier, says Higginbotham. They want to maximize their horse power and performance of the vehicle. So the only way to do that is with a higher octane fuel.Higginbotham says cars that require premium gas will run on the cheap stuff, but over time it could damage the engine. That's why Orlando Jackson of Brentwood bites the bullet and puts premium in his Mercedes.This is the first vehicle that I've ever owned that you could only put premium fuel in it, says Jackson. Honestly I'd rather not pay for premium but the performance I get from the car, it's worth it.So what does big oil say? Turns out it's not pushing one grade of gas over another.The reason we have different grades of gas is because we have different types of engines in our vehicles, says the Tennessee Petroleum Council's Mike Williams. The consumers really ought to be very careful and use the grade of gasoline that's recommended for the vehicle and the engine they have.Bottom line: nobody needs midgrade. If you buy it, you're wasting your money. Use premium only when it's required. For the majority of us, Edmunds.com says buy the cheapest gas you can find near your home or work, branded or not. There's one other distinction you may want to consider when filling up. It's called top tier gas. It contains up to 5 times more detergent than the law requires to reduce engine build up. It costs about a penny more a gallon. To find out which car companies recommend it and who's selling it, go to Fox17.com, click on FOX LINKS and look for TOP TIER FUEL. You can also find the lowest gas prices around there as well. You can find all our WASTE WATCH stories on Fox17.com. Just go to HOT TOPICS and click on WASTE WATCH. You can also submit your ideas for WASTE WATCH stories in that same section.