Tensing Investigation: Credibility questioned in prior case
684 views · Published 5 August 2015 · 4:34 · Indexed 6 November 2026
Channel: LOCAL 12 · 2015 · News & Politics
CINCINNATI (Rich Jaffe) -- In 2010, before Ray Tensing became a police officer, he was involved in a fight just off the UC campus. Tensing ended up as the victim in that fight with two other young men arrested and charged with assault. Local 12 News first reported about the case Friday, July 31. When it came to trial, and Tensing took the witness stand, the judge quickly dismissed the case and now it is known why. There was a stack of text messages between then 20-year-old Tensing and a group of his friends. Wednesday, July 29, after a grand jury indicted Tensing for the murder of Sam DuBose, Hamilton County prosecutor Joe Deters said he never should have been a cop in the first place. This is very possibly why he said that. As the result of the early morning fight, August 8, 2010, Tensing got seven staples in his scalp. According to the evidence pictures he sustained multiple injuries to his face. Legal documents obtained by Local 12 established that two individuals were arrested for felonious assault against Tensing. While the case went to trial in front of Judge Ralph Winkler, attorneys said it fell apart after Tensing, the first and only witness to testify, took the stand. That was largely because of text messages taken from his phone during the investigation. After Tensing was cross-examined by defense attorneys about those comments, the judge agreed to dismiss the entire case. Attorney Jay Clark obtained the messages through discovery and identified them for Local 12. He said when Tensing testified about the messages the case unraveled. "The way the case ended up, we never got to the point where we had to put on a defense. But after the judge heard his testimony the case was dismissed. Clients were found not guilty and the charges were dismissed. So in the big scheme these things were critical because it undermined his credibility to the point we didn't even have to put on a defense. The judge didn't believe him," said Clark. Tensing at the time was applying for jobs at various police departments and in those messages he said he was conducting his own investigation. In one of the messages he told a friend, Yea, I don't care how long it takes but if they don't catch them I'm gonna do it by myself. In another message from August 17, 2010, he said, I gave the detective my 'case file' on all the suspects tonight." "And it's clear he's extremely aggressive and would at least, it shows in his comments, not hesitate to be aggressive and that fit with what our clients told us. And I think he came across kind of as a bully," said Clark. While most of the messages were casual conversation, at issue were comments like the afternoon of the attack, a friend of Tensings sent him a message using racial slurs asking, Were they (the people who attacked him) African Americans or homosexuals? Tensing replied with the slang term for homosexuals. The following day, he told another friend, I wish I would of had my gun on me. Somebody would of left in a f....ing body bag." And again, six days later he texted another friend saying, I wish I had Mrs. 9 on me. Somebody wouldn't of been getting up off the sidewalk then." "I think he came across as arrogant. He came across as having something to hide cause when he was confronted with the messages I think there was at least two where he wanted to get together with his friend and get their stories together. He didn't recall those and I think he came across as disingenuous," said Clark. While the case began with the fight in 2010, before Tensing became a cop, Jay Clark said it's germane now because the upcoming murder trial for Tensing will be all about whether a judge or jury finds him credible, whether they can believe his version of the situation that ended up with him being charged for shooting and killing Sam DeBose. Tensing's current attorney Stew Mathews was not aware of this earlier case and had no comment on it. Because a judge acquitted the two young men charged with attacking Tensing in 2010, and the court expunged the record, Local 12 News is not naming them. That expungement and the fact Tensing was a victim in the case, means when Greenhills police did a background check on Tensing before hiring him, they would not have known about the case. A spokesperson for Prosecutor Joe Deters' office also said because the case was expunged, they have no comment about it. Follow Rich Jaffe on Twitter @rajaffe, and LIKE him on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter @Local12 and LIKE us on Facebook for updates!
More from this channel
-
2:50
Cincinnati Officer Indicted on Theft and Child Porn Charges -- LOCAL 12, WKRC-TV
-
0:48
Caesers CEO Addresses Chamber
-
0:36
$100 Million Dollar Cross Country Scam Involving Charity Donations
-
0:31
School Wants to Build Football Stadium
-
3:01
UC Player Dies in Accident in Butler County Saturday Night
-
3:08
Daily Sportscast: Tuesday, September 10
-
2:03
Brad and Lap talk Bengals 9-12
-
2:14
Daily Sportscast: Wednesday, September 11