Christoph Wolff on Bach Temperament : Why Beating Around the Bush?
2,186 views · Published 21 August 2017 · 20:43 · Indexed 16 November 2026
Channel: AuthenticSound · 2017 · Music
First a disclaimer : I have but the greatest respect for the great Bach scholar Christoph Wolff. His Biography on J.S.Bach is always close to me and I'm reading it now I believe for the third time. On the webpage of the great performer Wolfgang Rübsam, one can read an extensive article by the hand of Wolff on J.S.Bach's well-tempered clavier. Rübsam, by the way, plays this work on a Lautenwerk, an imortant instrument for Bach but one that never breaked through in the later 18th century. Here's a link to that page (http://bit.ly/2x3304s). As can be expected from the pen of someone like Christoph Wolff, there is much information on that single webpage, written in a style that is easy to read and with an ease that gives an impressive image of the vast knowledge Wolff has on Bach. At a certain point however, the topic of temperament is touched. No escape when talking on the WTC, but, as said earlier, perhaps on of the most avoided themes at the same time. At that point, something strange happens. When you are not at all familiar with at least some contemporary sources on temperament, you will not notice the twists Wolff suddenly starts to make in his narrative. He jumps from one author to another, connecting terms that he should not connect, making assumptions that contradict each other in the span of one paragraph, etc. If you are somewhat familiar with at least some sources, you start feeling somewhat uneasy with the way in which Wolff is trying to say nothing that hurts the facts too much and at the same time allows him to still align his story with what I would describe as Mainstream HIP. It simply does not make sense and the question that comes to my mind = why? ================================================= ☕ Become a die-hard supporter for Authentic Sound for only One cup of coffee... a month! And join the Patreon community : ▶https://www.patreon.com/authenticsound ================================================= The 3 'YOUR SELECTION' CDs now available on: 👉http://www.authenticsound.be/yourselection ================================================= Join our mailing list (and get the 356 page E-BOOK 'Your Selection' for FREE) here: 👉http://bit.ly/2loP6Gb ================================================= Subscribe for more videos 👉http://bit.ly/2mWWVB9 Website: ▶http://www.authenticsound.be
More from this channel
-
6:24
J.S.Bach ::Prelude & Fugue in F Major, BWV 880 (WK II) :: Wim Winters, Clavichord
-
21:48
V4: On my bookshelf: Ignaz Moscheles, diaries
-
21:43
V5: Tuning (part 2): setting a (first) temperament
-
36:59
V6: Beethoven's Sonata op.10/2: some aspects of interpretation
-
21:01
V7: Tuning (part3): tuning the complete instrument
-
29:04
V8: Tuning (part4): tuning a complete instrument ohne Worte
-
11:08
v10: What's in a name: AUTHENTIC SOUND
-
11:23
v13: My new pianoforte (1)