Prosecution Rests in Mother's Murder Trial
593 views · Published 30 August 2013 · 2:31 · Indexed 14 November 2026
Channel: WTVC NewsChannel 9 · 2013 · News & Politics
Jurors heard more about the personal side of Tasha Bates' life as day two of her murder trial unfolded. At about 3:15 this afternoon, the prosecution rested its case. 45 minutes later, the defense started its. Their first witness: Sandra Keith, Bates' mother.Keith described her daughter as a loving, patient mother.But she stands accused in the deaths of her 3-year-old son River and 5-year-old son Leland Bates. Both boys died from hyperthermia suffered in last summer's scorching heat. They were found in a car outside Bates' home on June 28; the temperature outside was 101 degrees. Detective Dewayne Scoggins said from the stand yesterday that Bates admitted leaving the boys unattended for up to an hour and finding them in the car.The question throughout the trial is how did the boys end up in the sweltering car? This afternoon, Keith offered some suggestions. She described her grandchildren as rambunctious, playful boys who loved to be outside all the time. She added both of them loved to play in the car and pretend they were driving it. Keith said 3-year-old River could even start the car and they had to keep the keys away from him.She went on to explain that the car's door handles didn't function properly and had to be manipulated to open. But that didn't stop the adventurous boys. I couldn't (open the doors), but they could. They opened the door for me quite a bit.Dr. Steven Cogswell, the medical examiner who performed the autopsies, testified there was no doubt the boys had been in a confined space like a car.After being rushed to Sky Ridge Medical Center in Cleveland, River's core body temperature was 109 degrees where he was pronounced dead. His older brother Leland was flown by LifeForce to Erlanger Medical Center in Chattanooga. There, his body temperature measured 104 degrees. Dr. Cogswell testified about how severe those readings are, especially for children. 109 degrees, you'll be comatose and you'll probably die. Above 108, you start seeing brain damage, irreversible brain damage. Above 104, you start seeing reversible kinds of changes, Dr. Cogswell said.Tasha Bates and the boy's biological father, Jonathan Bates, made the decision to pull Leland off of life support. Tasha's aunt, Tracy Honey, was also there and drove her back to Cleveland to talk with detective Scoggins. She was still very distraught. No she didn't want to go, she's just lost two babies, Honey said from the witness stand. Questioning then turned to Bates' parenting ability. Attorney Keith Roberts asked what kind of mother Bates was.Tasha did love her children, Honey said. Tasha was the best mother she knew how to be.Roberts asked what that meant. Just growing up her whole life, she's not really had that childhood. She's had to watch after her little brother and sister as she was growing up. She had a lot on her plate as a child. She didn't really have the stability she should have had.Throughout the trial, Bates has sat somewhat stoically in between her two attorneys. After the prosecution rested, the defense asked for a direct verdict. Judge Amy Reedy denied the motion to dismiss charges. The trial resumes tomorrow morning at 9:00.by John Madewell
More from this channel
-
2:37
Director Responds To 911 Investigation Report
-
2:07
What Happened to Money for Chattanooga Juvenile Curfew Room?
-
2:08
Lawyer: Expect Redesigned Anti-Gay Marriage Billboards
-
2:38
Darrell's NASCAR Minute - June 7, 2012
-
2:52
Dave's Diamond Darlings at Rivermont Dream League, June 8, 2012
-
2:39
Update: Murderer Takes Plea Deal
-
2:50
LiveU Brings Viewers Historic Live Shot
-
2:30
Chicken Farm Catches Fire in Bradley County