Family Distressed Over 'Not Guilty' Verdict
266 views · Published 19 May 2014 · 2:20 · Indexed 16 November 2026
Channel: WTVC NewsChannel 9 · 2014 · News & Politics
The family of a man killed after a large tugboat ran over his small fishing boat says they're not satisfied with Monday's verdict. A jury found tugboat captain Charles Warren Luetke (pictured) not guilty in the June 2010 deaths of two fisherman. "That day has never left. It's been right on top of my mind the whole time," said Melvin Wilkey. Wilkey says the past four years have been a living nightmare. He's been trying to find closure in his brother's death. "There's not been any justice done in this accident, except for the tugboat operator not having to go to jail," says Wilkey. The operator of that tugboat, Charles Warren Luetke, was acquitted Monday morning. In June of 2010 Luetke was piloting a tugbot pushing nine barges down the Tennessee River. He ran over a fishing boat, carrying three men. Two of those men died- Tim Spidle and Melvin's brother, Richard Wilkey. A third person on the fishing boat, David Wilkey survived. "My little brother had been fishing up and down that river for over 30-years, he was scared of barges, he wouldn't let one run over him. Something isn't right about it," said Melvin Wilkey. The survivor on board the fishing boat said their motor wouldn't start. He said they tried to paddle out of the barge's path, but didn't make it. A state accident report said that Luetke's vision was obstructed and there was no lookout. But, during the trial, Luetke's lawyer claimed that the fisherman were drinking - and that was what led to the men's deaths. "The rules and navigation apply to all boaters on the river, not just professional towboat captains and at the end of the day everyone is responsibile for abiding by them," says Samuel Hudson, Luetke's attorney. Hudson said his client is a professional pilot and took actions that day based on his training and experience. He says this was simply a tragic accident. Melvin Wilkey said now he will focus on putting this behind him.
More from this channel
-
2:37
Director Responds To 911 Investigation Report
-
2:07
What Happened to Money for Chattanooga Juvenile Curfew Room?
-
2:08
Lawyer: Expect Redesigned Anti-Gay Marriage Billboards
-
2:38
Darrell's NASCAR Minute - June 7, 2012
-
2:52
Dave's Diamond Darlings at Rivermont Dream League, June 8, 2012
-
2:39
Update: Murderer Takes Plea Deal
-
2:50
LiveU Brings Viewers Historic Live Shot
-
2:30
Chicken Farm Catches Fire in Bradley County