Lawsuit Filed Against CCA & Hamilton County Sheriff

629 views · Published 27 March 2014 · 3:09 · Indexed 16 November 2026

Channel: WTVC NewsChannel 9 · 2014 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

Violating women's rights - that's the accusation against CCA Silverdale and Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Hammond.A lawsuit filed last week says a policy of shackling pregnant female inmates during labor and delivery is a clear violation of women's rights. Charity Flerl is named as the plaintiff.  She says while she was incarcerated, her legs and arms were tied down nearly the entire time of her baby's birth.To be clear, the Hamilton County Jail only houses male inmates.  They send their female inmates to CCA.We spoke to the attorney who filed the lawsuit who told us shackling female prisoners during labor and delivery is dangerous and just flat-out cruel. It seems a bit extreme to me, says Gabriel Smith. They're criminals, so you never know what they might do, says Monica Johnson. Attorney Chris Clem said his client; Charity Flerl was arrested last June on failure to pay child support. She was housed at CCA for several months before she went into labor. They took her to Erlanger and they kept her shackled the entire time, they kept her legs, feet, waist shackled. When she had to actually give birth, they unshackled the legs from each other, but then they shackled them to the bed and same with her arms, says attorney Chris Clem. He goes on to ask, What's the purpose of it other than curling in human punishment?Attorney Clem says there's no reason she was even partially shackled during birth. There's no indication that she's violent to herself or to others, no indication that she's a flight risk, there are two armed guards in the room, not posted outside the room, but in the room next to her, says Clem. This comes on the heels of a case in Nashville last year. That's when a federal judge ordered that Nashville's policy of shackling women when giving birth be changed. Attorney Clem wants Hamilton County to follow suit.Just change the policy, keep your armed security guards there, if you do have reason to think they're violent, fine maybe shackle them, but most of these prisoners are not there for violent offenses, says Clem. Meanwhile Sheriff Jim Hammond was also named in the lawsuit.  But, he's unclear how he's involved.I guess that'll be up to whoever filed the lawsuit to determine what relevance that has to do with the Hamilton County sheriff, says Sheriff Hammond. We've learned that CCA has a contract with the Hamilton County government, but not with the sheriff's office.  County attorney Ruben Taylor had no comment when we called on Tuesday afternoon. Meanwhile, CCA wouldn't tell us their policy for shackling women at their jail, but gave us this statement late Tuesday saying, While we are unable to speak to the specifics of this case, our dedicated, professional corrections staff is firmly committed to the health and safety of the inmates entrusted to our care.Depend on us to keep you posted as this lawsuit moves forward.By Jerry Askin

More from this channel