Film review- The Hobbit, art or merchandising?
2,006 views · Published 17 December 2012 · 6:48 · Indexed 10 November 2026
Channel: Stephen Hayes · 2012 · Entertainment
Caution plot spoilers. My wife and I are long term hard core Tolkien fans. We have worn out 2 sets of his books by constant re-reading over 4 decades, visited Tolkein's grave in Oxford and several times been to the Eagle and Child pub where he talked about dragons and elves with C S Lewis and other literary friends. I want his poem 'Bilbo's Last Song' read out at my funeral. Many thousands, in not hundreds of thousands, of people have the same affection for Tolkien that we have. His legacy is completely unique. That's why we're so upset at the influence that accountants and salesmen of tie-in merchandise have so obviously had on the first hobbit film which we saw on the day of release last week. We accept the need for some liberties to be taken when translating a book to a film. But The Hobbit: an Unexpected Journey, although very good in parts and a success overall, contained unacceptable prostitution of Tolkien. Radagast, the goblin king and several of the dwarves were figures of fun. There was a chase involving a rabbit pulled sled which was reminiscent of the Ewoks in Star Wars. I thought 'I smell merchandising!' and sure enough, Googling on 'hobbit games' today, there are vast numbers of film related games and other trash for sale for much money. It is quite clear that the film was designed around creating a demand for and advertising the merchandise. Tolkien and his millions of fans deserve better than this. I am not anti-profit, but this goes way beyond honest profit and deserves to be called what it is-prostitution. Send Peter Jackson and Saul Zaentz and their accountants and bankers a message. Do not buy any hobbit related merchandise, other than of course the book. The second and third films are yet to be edited, they need to be better than this. Tolkien and his fans deserve better than this.
More from this channel
-
0:36
Diary of an English orchard-Easter hail
-
2:54
Diary of an English orchard-March 2008
-
6:23
September orchard walk
-
3:28
happy Christmas from the orchard
-
2:12
cider apple 2 months after grafting over
-
0:56
Train through Mallorca almond orchard part 1
-
1:13
evening heron into sunset
-
2:04
Apple varieties Miller's Seedling