Reality Check: A Look At Bonds Set In Local Counties

920 views · Published 3 November 2013 · 4:06 · Indexed 30 October 2026

Channel: NBC 15 · 2013 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

MOBILE, Ala. (WPMI) In most cases, when a person commits a crime, a bond is set by a judge. But some law enforcement officers in Mobile County believe bonds are set too low, lower than bonds set in neighboring counties.Mobile County Sheriff Sam Cochran said for the most part judges set bonds higher in Baldwin County than they do in Mobile County. And a widow in Prichard can attest to that after her husband's suspected killer was released from jail after just a few days.Felicia Norman lost her husband Bryant Norman to violence on Easter Sunday.The grandchildren, they miss him so much. And it's hard, it's hard, said Norman.Prichard Police said her former next door neighbor, 63-year-old Silas Davis, shot and killed Bryant Norman after an argument. He was charged with murder and retired Mobile County District Judge Charles McKnight set his bond at $20,000.I was mostly hurt and didn't believe what I was hearing that the bond was set that low because I said, that's impossible that someone can get out that just shot somebody in the chest for no reason, said Norman.I certainly think $20,000 for a murder case is extremely low, said Sheriff Cochran.He and his deputies have arrested thousands of criminals in Mobile County. And when one of those criminals is accused of committing a violent crime like armed robbery or murder, he or she will usually appear before a judge for a bond hearing.Cochran said more often than not, bonds are set higher in Baldwin County than they are in Mobile County.Yes, I've known this for years. I think you can see the differences in bond amounts. I think you can take it a step further. I've noticed for years that you'll see stiffer sentences from someone in a rural county versus someone in Mobile County. It's just in Mobile County over time you'll see more murders than you will in a rural county. You see so many of those offenses that our judges sort of gauge it relative to how many of those cases they see.And you compare it with a rural county that doesn't see too many attempted murders or murders and you'll see a striking difference in the bonds, said Cochran.When Local 15 started comparing bond amounts in Baldwin and Mobile counties, we found a dozen people in Baldwin County still in jail with $1 million bonds: including Fred Weiss, who's charged with murder. And Charles Harris and Jonathan Jones, both charged with drug trafficking.Mario Mendez comes close with a $805,000 bond for kidnapping among other charges.Only one person is booked in Mobile County Metro Jail with a $1 million bond and that's Gregory Hall. He's charged with capital murder.Drug trafficking offenders in Mobile like Brandon Porter and Arius Samuels have bonds set at $20,000 and $50,000.Even attempted murder suspect Devin Evans, who officials said shot at a sheriff's deputy in Mobile County, is in jail with a $125,000 bond.In Baldwin County, Steven Pinson, who is charged with attempted murder, had bond set at $500,000. Police said Pinson shot a tourist in a case of road rage in Orange Beach.I'm not aware of disparity. I can only comment on the approach of this court in setting bonds, said Mobile County District Judge Joe Basenberg.He said he doesn't know what goes on in Baldwin County because he bases his decisions on the Alabama Rules of Criminal Procedure. He also said every case is drastically different making it hard to compare any two.A judge considers many factors when setting bond.One of the things we look at is the prior criminal history, general reputation, his employment, connections to the community, said Judge Basenberg.And everyone is innocent until proven guilty.The purpose of bond is to guarantee someone attends the sessions of court that they're supposed to attend. The other thing to keep in mind is that bond is not to be used as a pretrial punishment. Bond is used as I said to secure the appearance of a person in court for later functions, said Basenberg.Remember that $20,000 bond set by retired Judge Charles McKnight? It's not out of line according to the bond schedule recommended by the Alabama Supreme Court.According to the schedule, people with murder should have a bond set between $15,000 and $ 75,000.As for Felicia Norman, she can't change the past. She can only hope for justice in the future. I put it all in the Lord's hands. Whatever God see fit to do that will be fine with me, said Norman.Both Sheriff Cochran and Judge Basenberg said that what the state's criminal justice system needs most is more funding. Often times a defendant has to wait a couple of years before his or her case goes to trial.

More from this channel