Plains/MAWSS Hearing Day Two

37 views · Published 30 December 2013 · 2:16 · Indexed 14 November 2026

Channel: NBC 15 · 2013 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

MOBILE, Ala. (WPMI)  Tuesday makes the second day a judge is hearing arguments over an oil pipeline in Mobile. The hearing will decide if Plains will be granted permission to pursue the pipeline through Mobiles Drinking water shed. Plains wants to condemn a piece of land in order to continue the pipeline.  It appears Plains did everything it could to discredit the information MAWSS has used to justify rerouting the pipeline outside the water shed. MAWSS has commissioned a study through the University of South Alabama. Dr. Whelton conducted the study which looks at the consequences of a spill near Big Creek Lake. It suggests that a spill in the water shed would have a negative environmental impact and jeopardize Mobiles sole drinking water supply. Tuesday Plains brought one of their experts to the stand to testify otherwise. Robert Wood, CEO of Joiner and Associates, is a geologist. He said he assessed Big Creek Lake and surrounding land. He claims a spill near Big Creek lake is highly unlikely. He stated one is ten times more likely to get in a car crash than for a spill to occur based on his assessment of crude oil pipeline leaks. Wood suggest that since Plains will build the pipeline 90 feet below the surface, if a spill occurred it would take more than 5,000 years for the oil to reach the surface. To sit there and say in a court room well its not going to happen in the next 50 years. Its not going to happen in the next 100 years, that's not adequate science at all. The risk will be there once it leaks out of that pipeline, said MAWSS Attorney Don Beebe.  Unlike the MAWSS Website about our project, the info today was based on scientific data that really shows facts about the safety of the line, said Plains All American Manager of Communications Brad Leone. Plains continued to push measures it has taken to exceed federal pipeline standards. The pipeline company brought another expert witness to the stand. Mark Hereth is an engineer and pipeline expert. Hereth says the current route of the pipeline is the best route. Plains originally generated three routes. All three are in the water shed. One parallels parts of Schillinger Road and the other crosses through a popular golf course. Experts told the Judge Robert Smith, that the two other routes were not because of the need to maintenance. Hereth added the areas were too developed and that Plains is concerned about third parties possibly interfering with the pipeline. Hereth said the current route travels along Alabama Powers corridor which makes it easy for construction and allows both companies to share maintenance responsibilities and information since their own the same right way. Leone said, It's the safest route that we can select. Weve done a number of safety enhancements including the idea of a horizontal directional drilling below the Hamilton Creek and doing all we can to make this a safe line. Beebe said, They assume there's never going to be a spill. This witness just testified its highly unlikely to be a spill. What he factored out the 9 largest spills that occurred in the US one of which is from Plains.The hearing will continue Wednesday morning at 9 a.m.

More from this channel