Woman Sentenced in Animal Abuse Case

555 views · Published 11 March 2015 · 2:04 · Indexed 27 October 2026

Channel: NBC 15 · 2015 · News & Politics

Watch on YouTube

BAY MINETTE, Ala. (WPMI) Who could forget the Purple Hearted Puppies, more than 100 hundred animals, including dogs and cats were abused and left to die at a boarding facility in Summerdale. 

It's been three years since the abuse was discovered and on this day after some legal twists and turns, the woman who owned the facility will now have to serve jail time.

It's not exactly what prosecutors wanted. 

The abuse is what got Sharon Dueitt in 2012. Ignoring her plea deal with prosecutors to not own any pets and then lying about it after posting it on Facebook is what had her in court on February 11.

"At heart we would like to see her go to jail for a whole lot longer than a year and never be able to have an animal again. But unfortunately the law does not allow that," said Baldwin County District Attorney Hallie Dixon. 

Prosecutors wanted the max jail time for Dueitt. Her defense lawyer fought for leniency, saying she has a low I.Q. and suffers from a brain injury. They also testified that Dueitt had been getting death threats.

"If you take a woman who has a mental disability, who has lost her mother and to make anonymous death threats is cowardly and despicable," said defense attorney Liam Scully. 

"There is no mental deficiency. She has a speech impediment, that's a line she's been selling from the get go. And it's also offensive and it should be offensive to anybody who cares about people who do have mental challenges," said Dixon. 

In the end Dueitt's sentence comes down to 1,000 hours of community cleaning animal cages and a weekend in jail.

"I particularly like the fact that he told her that she should know what it's like to sit behind a cage. It's nowhere near good enough because you would have to deprive her of food and water to make it real," said Dixon.

Members and volunteers with the humane society left the courtroom frustrated.

"We are disappointed that it's only a weekend in jail but we are thankful the judge did recognize the severity of her crime," said Deneen Balisterewith Baldwin County's Humane Society. 

The outcome makes history in Baldwin County because it's the first animal abuse felony conviction in the county.

Sharon Dueitt will have to turn herself at the Baldwin County jail come Friday

More from this channel